"THEY SAID IT" ARCHIVES
July, 2008
Home of the Wildland
Firefighter
| DATE |
|
| 7/31 |
Re: Wildland Firefighter Burn Treatment/Transportation
Michelle and NWCG-SHWT Members,
I wanted to send a quick note of thanks to you and your group for taking up...
addressing... and correcting the issues relating to the standard of care for
wildland firefighter burn injuries.
Without your steadfast commitment to the issues, there would have been
insurmountable interagency hurdles to overcome. We all know there will be more
rounds of educating others about OWCP (or other agency) processes and roadblocks
that stand in the way when firefighters are injured, but by setting a national
standard of care (burns or otherwise), the NWCG SHWT has shown true leadership.
Your commitment to providing the best standard of care to our injured
firefighters, regardless of agency or affiliation, is a great example of our
emerging 21st Century trend toward high reliability organizing within the
wildland fire community.
In terms of the not so "rare event" you mention where the attending physician
will not authorize transfer to a Regional Burn Center, several action oriented
groups such as the Wildland Firefighter Foundation, the Federal Wildland Fire
Service Association, and others (CDF Firefighters Local 2881, NFFE, AFGE, IAFF,
etc.) have regular contact with burn care treatment specialists willing to offer
their services and recommendations, if needed, to help streamline the process(es).
Take care and keep those around you safer.
Sincerely,
/s/ Kenneth Kempter
Federal Wildland Fire Service Association |
| 7/31 |
"Give me a break" & others:
Senator Feinstein's office is looking closely at the engine availability i.e.
those at 7 day, 5 day, 3 day and not moving. They are fully aware of the fact
that those hired or promoted may not be on board as soon as the Agency would
like Congress to think.
Unfortunately the Agency fails to state the facts that just because you have
people, it doesn't necessarily mean you have people in the spots you need. The
ANF had a lot of GS-5s but no overhead.
The Senator is obviously aware that if you promote a bunch of folks you create
vacancies elsewhere so do the numbers really increase? So please be assured that
the full impact/details of firehire and any other issue will be provided to
Congress by the FWFSA and others without the obligatory spin, smoke & mirrors
etc.
Now, if the Agency could/would explain to Congress just how long folks will need
to try and be on computers during a very active season doing admin stuff whether
they are new promotees, new hires or their new supervisors, I might be
impressed.
It would certainly be a breath of fresh air if the Agency would actually be
straight forward with Congress rather than try to hide the details. The Agency
should know by now that organizations like the FWFSA and others will get the
facts to Congress anyway so why not be aboveboard rather than looking foolish by
offering half truths and slight of hand tricks.
Maybe they are still in denial that they have a fire program that is falling
apart. Who knows. Keep the info coming to us and the Feinstein's office.
Individual Forest info will be forwarded to the congressional reps who cover the
area.
Stay Safe & thanks,
Casey |
| 7/31 |
72 hour Report on Andy Palmer's death. 72 hour Expanded Report, Dutch Creek
Incident; Iron Complex; Shasta-Trinity NF, Region 5, July 25, 2008
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/showthread.php?p=27369 |
| 7/31 |
Ab and all,
First my and my co-worker's deepest sympathy's on our latest losses.
When we lose one of "our" own it really hit's home. And when i say "our" i mean
all agencies not just the FS. WE are all in the fight together, differences
aside.
Second to add to the firehire comments. I think Gimme a Break hit the nail right
on the head!
I know in my district alone, a lot of positions (like probably 95%, i have
not done the exact math) were filled by our own 5's and 6's (PROMOTION/already a
5 and got the developmental position) and the only 7 spot was filled by someone
who seems (at least on paper, we have not met him yet due to the drug testing
hold back) to be a competent, yet engine boss unqualified! (smell an
underqualification here, i know you don't have to have it to get the job, but i
think it's quite funny that you must to take a "detail") firefighter.
I really am enjoying the stats that everyone are posting as far as nitty
gritty #'s etc.. I would encourage everyone with the knowledge to collaborate
and let's get a break down of #'s of spots filled/available etc....... and
really break it down to each forest/district and we can do our own math and with
some good solid #'s to present this to Casey and the wonderful folks of the
FWFSA for them to use in upcoming "BATTLES"
just a thought,
Lovin the Lake
FWFSA and Casey have been collecting. Ab. |
| 7/31 |
Regarding the FireHire -
My guess is that we robbed Peter to pay Paul. How many vacancies were created
by filling the FireHire jobs? Are they reporting these numbers??? Filling
positions
with unqualified or marginally qualified firefighters is ludicrous. Where is
"safety first"?
Silly of course of me to ask...as long as they meet the X-118's they're
qualified, right?
Give me a break!! |
| 7/31 |
Does anyone have input on working for the BIA?
May I add my condolences for Chief Packer.
LT. RET. |
| 7/31 |
Chief Packer's body arrived home yesterday afternoon via USFS DC-3.
Below is the
link to the article in The News Tribune (Tacoma, WA), as
well as video story
from KOMO-4 (Seattle ABC affiliate), and KIRO-7
(Seattle, CBS).
www.thenewstribune.com/news/local/story/429343.html
www.komonews.com/news/26125064.html
www.kirotv.com/news/17043915/detail.html |
| 7/31 |
View Entire Article Here
http://home.nps.gov/applications/digest/headline.cfm?type=Incidents&id=4068
OLYMPIC NATIONAL PARK
Memorial Service Set For Firefighter Andy Palmer
A memorial service for park firefighter Andy Palmer, who was killed while
fighting a wildland fire last week, will be held on Monday.
The service will be held from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. on Monday, August 4th, at
McCurdy Pavilion in Fort Worden State Park in Port Townsend. Director Mary Bomar
and Regional Director Jon Jarvis will be joining park employees at the service
and will be spending time with park staff at park headquarters afterwards.
An incident management team (Denny Ziemann, IC) will be arriving over the next
few days to organize the NPS participation in the service and to assist with
logistics. A CISD team is also in the park to provide assistance.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
God Speed Andy. |
| 7/31 |
www.ptleader.com/main.asp?SectionID=36&SubSectionID=55&ArticleID=21472&TM=48632.9
Memorial service is Monday at Fort Worden for Andy Palmer, fallen firefighter
Memorial service is Monday
A public memorial service, a celebration of life for Andrew Jackson Palmer, is
scheduled for 10 a.m. Monday, Aug. 4 at McCurdy Pavilion, Fort Worden State Park
in Port Townsend. Everyone is welcome.The pavilion can seat more than 1,000
people, which may be necessary because Andy has deep connections in both Port
Townsend and Port Angeles.
As a fallen firefighter, a large number of emergency services personnel from
around the region are expected to attend.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This is a really nice article about Andy with pictures.
Sammie |
| 7/31 |
Daniel Packer:
His loss is felt deeply here in Montana, here in Missoula. I have friends
that knew him well. They are devastated.
CathieCondolences, Cathie. Please let your friends know we are grieving as
well. Ab. |
| 7/31 |
The fire hire really did help the Inyo, the management on the forest did a
excellent
job filling and recruiting, we will be better staffed next season and the forest
has
some excellent new employees. With that said, we are not at the numbers Mr. Pena
has stated.
Inyo Staffing7 Forest Service Type 3 Engines
3...7 day engines
3...5 day engines
1 unstaffed
Vacancies
1 GS 11 FMO
1 GS 8 SFEO
3 GS 7 FEO
2 GS 6 AFEO
18 GS 5 senior firefighter positions. ( we have a some new GS 5 apprentices,
GS 4 apprentices and a quite few SCEPs all great employees.) |
| 7/31 |
And another with info forwarded on to Casey. Casey,
I have seen the data published by Jim Pena and have run the numbers on my
forest. When you do the math without all the vacant GS 5 Senior Firefighter
positions the numbers are pretty close. When you include all the vacant GS 5
Senior Firefighter positions the percentage of positions filled is about 68%.
Senator Feinstein and Congress would be shocked to discover the true number of
vacant jobs. The jobs they did fill are with under qualified employees. Jim may
argue the GS 5's are filled with apprentices but until they convert the spot is
vacant. Jim Pena is doing the firefighters of the USFS a great dis-service by
changing the imput data and excluding all the vacant GS 5 Senior Firefighter
positions. Thank you for getting the message out that the numbers are incorrect
the data is tainted.
CA FF |
| 7/30 |
To: Just another Digger and all others:
The briefing paper about the recent FireHire put out by the Forest Service
leaves out a great amount of detail as to the actual impact the FireHire/Promotion
Party will have immediately or in the future.
As expected, the Agency has issued a briefing paper which would suggest they did
a marvelous job filling positions. Fortunately, those in the federal wildland
firefighting community and Congress know the details of the FireHire and the
less than immediate impact the event will have for any given Forest.
Lots of FEOs...but few have a CDL and everyone is on fires so who's going to
train them? Some Forests have gotten some captains from out of state but we all
know you don't just throw a new captain on an engine in R5 and the crew is ready
to roll... although from my discussion with Mr. Pena, I believe he thinks that
to be the case. Some won't be on the books until the end of the season.
The briefing paper fails to address the actual time frame for getting these
folks ready to respond and the added stress hiring level 3 employees will have
on their new supervisors.
Further, although the Agency has addressed entry level hiring, it has still
failed to offer any [emphasis added] insight as to what it plans to do to keep
its employees.
I would strongly urge you and any others who have factual information on the
impact, or lack thereof of the recent FireHire to communicate directly with
Devin Rhinerson in Senator Feinstein's DC office at either: 202-224-2004 or by
email at:
Devin_Rhinerson@feinstein.senate.gov.
A reminder: when contacting congressional staff please don't use your government
computer/address or phone.
If anyone has any questions or if they feel more comfortable sending your
information to the FWFSA as many already have, please feel free to do so at
208-775-4577 or cjudd@fwfsa.org.
Thanks,
Casey Judd
Business Manager
FWFSA |
| 7/30 |
As you probably know the LA times is running a story about wildland fires.
Here is the link to part two
www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-wildfires29-2008jul29,0,4296840,full.story
Oceanfire |
| 7/30 |
I was in the left front seat of the CWN Jet Bell Ranger 206 Helicopter that
crashed on the
Strayler Fire on July 26, 2004, and I am looking for any photos that may have
been taken
of the crash site and the rescue. I have some photos of the crash site after it
was burned over
by the spot fire but I hear that there may be some photos of the site prior to
the burn over. I
would like the photos in order to illustrate story of the rescue operation that
took place.
Bill Baxter
CAL-FIRE – Mendocino Unit
Green Sheet As I recall, it was quite dramatic. Ab. |
| 7/30 |
To Whom It May Concern,
The July Fire Hire Briefing Update Paper dated July 29, 2008 issued by Jim Pena
is inaccurate about the staffing levels here at the Tahoe Management Unit.
We currently have 2 engines 5 day effective. 1 watertender vacant. 1 squad boss
fuels vacant. 1 prevention position vacant.
Just Another Digger
|
| 7/30 |
Groundpig
The article mentioned "Olympic National Park Firefighter Andrew Palmer".
midwest afmo |
| 7/30 |
Ab,
Yo, this is your old friend Groundpig. I've been underground for some
time, but this brought me up.
This came out from the USDA. I find it very interesting there is not one
mention of the term FIREFIGHTER. My gut feeling is this is by design.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20250
Message from the Secretary:
Each year, USDA's brave men and women in the
Forest Service battle wildfires to protect both public and private property
and ensure the continuation of our Nation's forests as ecological and
recreational centers. Over this past weekend, two gentlemen tragically lost
their lives assisting the Forest Service in its mission. While neither was
a direct member of the USDA family, each was working side-by-side with our
employees to battle wildfires in California.
On July 25, while securing a fire line on the
Eagle Fire in California, Olympic National Park Firefighter Andrew Palmer
died from injuries suffered during mop-up activities. Mr. Palmer, who was
based out of Port Angeles, Washington, was only 18 at the time of his
death. On July 26, a fire suppression team was scouting the Panther Fire,
also in California, in preparation for the team to take over fire fighting
activities the next day. One of the team members lost his life when he was
overrun by the fire front. The probable victim has been identified as
Daniel Packer, Chief of East Pierce County Fire and Rescue in Bonney Lake,
Washington. He was 49.
In honor and memory of these brave gentlemen,
flags at USDA are being flown at half mast from dusk on July 28 until
sundown on August 2. Please keep them in your thoughts and prayers, and
join with me in extending my deepest gratitude and most heartfelt sympathy
to their families.
Thanks, Groundpig. Ab. |
| 7/30 |
National Interagency Fire Center
3833 S. Development Avenue
Boise, Idaho 83705
July 29, 2008To: Geographic Area Coordinating Group Chairs
From: National Multi Agency Coordinating Group
Subject: Safety Stand Down: August 1st
Two fatalities occurred over the weekend in two separate Northern California
fires. A recent spike in accident/injury trends has also created concerns for
firefighter safety. To date we have exceeded the number of deaths in wildland
fire operations for 2008 that we experienced during all of 2007. In an effort to
draw attention to wildland firefighter safety, NMAC is requesting that all
geographic areas take one hour during the operational period of August 1st to
emphasize safety practices.
Firefighter safety is and continues to be our first priority. The commitment to
and accountability for safety is a joint responsibility of all firefighters,
managers, and administrators. Individuals must be responsible for their own
performance and accountability.
Suggested areas of emphasis are:
- Primary means of safe wildland fire operations is through aggressive
risk management.
- Consistently evaluate fireline tactics and adjust tactics as environmental
and human factor conditions change—Review Risk Management Process in the IRPG, Page 1.
- Exercise extreme caution when working in timber canopy areas—assume
every tree has some level of hazard associated with it. Review “PRINCIPLES
OF HAZARD TREE RISK MANAGEMENT” at:
www.nwcg.gov/teams/shwt/httf/training_education/s212/ht-risk-mgmt.pdf
- Driving standards and limitations need to be applied and enforced.
Drivers should not be exceeding 10 hours behind the wheel driving time
(state CDL limitations may be more stringent). This applies to all drivers
including agency employees, ADs, and contractors. Every effort should be
made to avoid driving between 2200 and 0500 hours.
- Dehydration and Fatigue – constantly monitor firefighter’s water and
electrolyte intake to avoid dehydration episodes. Dehydration and long work
hours coupled with poor air quality all impact fatigue—monitor and provide
rest opportunities for firefighters and support personnel.
- Avoid complacency in aviation operations and reinforce the aviation risk
assessment process to increase awareness of flight hazards and risks,
attention to risk mitigation, and to assert added attention to the following
topics:
For additional wildland fire safety information, please refer to:
www.nifc.gov/safety.html
We ask that every fire manager take this time to emphasize firefighter safety
and appropriate management of risk. We appreciate all the efforts of every
firefighter and support personnel. Let’s do everything in our power to return
everyone home safely this fire season.
/s/ Lyle Carlile
Chair, NMAC (orig pdf file for printing if desired:
NMAC-SafetyStandDown080108.pdf) |
| 7/30 |
The ultimate packing machine
www.bostondynamics.com/content/sec.php?section=BigDog
Man just to think no more hose pack hikes..... watch the whole vid for some
crazy stuff.
JS
The slow motion is very interesting. Ab. |
| 7/30 |
Islander,
Thank you for clarifying your previous post. Very well said. Amen.
Blue |
| 7/29 |
Dear AB & All:
It's hard to decide when sufficient time to reflect on the losses the wildland
firefighting community has been dealt this past weekend has passed in order to
follow up on questions/responses here on TheySaid. Thus AB, I defer to you as to
when you feel it appropriate to place this on TheySaid.
When I hear the word "snag" I immediately think of Danny Holmes of the Arrowhead
Hotshots. A few days after my birthday I think of Heather, Steve & John from the
Stanza Fire and the memorial in Chester California for them. In October it will
be BDF Engine 57 and throughout the year, so many names of those who gave their
lives in this truly honorable profession.
With that said, I hope I am not out of line, or being insensitive in responding
to a couple of posts that showed up prior to the wildland firefighting community
learning of the deaths of Chief Packer and Andrew Palmer. However the sharing of
thoughts and ideas is what makes this site so vital to the community.
To Cynic:
The simple answer to your question of whether P&P would even be an issue if
Cal-Fire wasn't getting it is: ABSOLUTELY. The issue has been around since a
time when feds were actually better paid than "CDF" firefighters.
The issue is that the employer of federal wildland firefighters, the Federal
Government via federal land management agencies is paying non-federal
firefighters P&P based upon salaries that are already significantly higher than
their own federal firefighters.
Our point is straightforward. P&P is a part of a series of pay & benefit
components which, if implemented, would strengthen the infrastructure of our
federal wildland firefighting forces by making a significant positive impact on
retention of well tenured/experienced firefighters.
Strengthening the infrastructure of the inherently less-expensive federal forces
would allow the federal land management agencies to reduce (not eliminate) their
current over-reliance on higher-priced non-federal resources and ultimately save
the American taxpayer staggering sums in suppression costs each year.
I would encourage everyone to read the current multi-part article on fire costs
by the L.A. Times. While it fails to address the nexus between federal land
management agency fire program policy with the proliferation of contracting &
cooperators on fires, some of the examples of spending on such wildfires should
be a wake-up call to Congress and the American Taxpayer.
To: Justthinkingoutloud:
The FWFSA is certainly cognizant of the traditional role the militia has played
on fire assignments. We know that for many years, the number of those actually
responding to such assignments has diminished significantly to the point that
even the General Accounting Office (GAO) referred to it in one of its reports.
Candidly, there is no incentive for the "militia" to spend days or weeks away
from their families in support of wildfires or other emergency incidents.
As I previously posted, the original intent of our P&P language was to create as
broad an application as possible. However, with the current climate in Congress,
the mandated "flat budgets" required by the current administration and the
ever-present "what's it going to cost" and "how are you going to pay for it"
questions from those in Congress, the FWFSA's obvious priority must be its dues
paying members, the vast majority of which are those employees eligible for
federal firefighter special retirement.
We know that what the FWFSA accomplishes will benefit far more than the number
of dues-paying members we have. We know that there will always be those who want
to "play" but don't want to pay. This is an expensive business and as a result
our absolute priority is to our loyal, dues-paying members.
Many militia personnel are members of NFFE which we have worked very well with
over the last year on a number of issues. What we have encouraged folks like
yourself to do is to become better informed as to NFFE's case history as it
relates to firefighters and who is defined as a "primary firefighter." Decisions
have been rendered that make that moniker very broad.
Ultimately, if the FWFSA is the organization that spends the bucks to get the
language crafted, authored and introduced, then we obviously have to focus on
our members. There is current interest in Congress to create a P&P "pilot
program" since there are so many variables that would impact the actual cost of
P&P in any given season. The idea is to run such a program for 2-3 seasons, look
at the costs and then make some permanent program decisions.
As some may be aware, Sen. Feinstein has recently sought an additional $904
Million for the fire season, specifically directing $25 million of that for
"retention." We are currently working with her office to define precisely what
she meant and whether such funds could be "earmarked" for a P&P program.
Thanks for the opportunity to respond. Our prayers and thoughts continue to go
out to not only the families, friends and co-workers of those lost and injured
recently, but to all of you on the lines.
Casey |
| 7/29 |
Ab-
Memorial for Chief Packer is scheduled for
Thursday, August 7th, 1400 hrs;
at Christian Faith Center,
33645 20th AVE South, Federal Way, WA.
The public is welcome to attend. I'll post information about apparatus/honors
as it becomes available.
There is a memorial fund set up at Washington Mutual Bank - Fire Chief Dan
Packer Memorial, Acct # 3170484930. Checks may be mailed to:
East Pierce Professional Firefighters, L3520
PO Box 7500
Bonney Lake, WA 98391
More info as it becomes available.
-FireBill |
| 7/29 |
OFBA:
You betcha the FBANs have one of the toughest jobs out there, and one of the
most important to get right. And many years have gone into producing their
analysis tools. I wouldn't want to see them or the IMETs dissed, which is what
started me writing in the first place ...
Still Out There ... |
| 7/29 |
The
Panther 24 hour Report is out from NWCG. The
Eagle Fire - Iron Complex 24 hour Report is out from NWCG. Ab. |
| 7/29 |
I guess maybe I was less articulate about my thoughts than was needed.
So often when we hear about a firefighter lost, we think it won’t happen to us.
Then it happens to a friend. Someone my age. Someone who was fought fires as
long as I have. Someone who held the same job, held the same positions, someone
I fought fire along side. Someone who made good sound decisions, who preached
and followed all the safety guidelines.
And you realize, yeah, it can happen to me too. Despite all the years, all the
fires, it can happen to you too.
Complacency comes in many forms. Sometimes it comes from believing you’ve seen
it all and you know you’ll never cross the line. This isn’t a indictment of Dan…
it’s a realization that anyone on the fireline lives with a real risk. Even us “oldtimers”.
islanderThanks for the clarification, islander, and so sorry for your and
your community's loss. Ab. |
| 7/29 |
This was written several years ago...seems appropriate to share at this time to
let sawyers and fallers know how important they are to the other fire fighters
on the line.
The Faller
Broken topped snag
busted at its base.
The faller sizes up the forest giant
a grin upon his face.
Vented flames midway up,
cracks in the trees armor.
Two pulls and the saw roars
echoing across the forest floor.
Trees of black rise to the sky
surrounding the sawyers task.
Ear plugs in to quite the din
goggles worn like Zorro’s mask..
Undercut to sway the fall
as he moves around the tree.
The back cut made and a “timber”
shouted warning for all to heed.
The snag came down
with a thud and cloud of dust.
The safety for incoming crews
a must.
A quick check for widow makers
that might be waiting to fall,
fire crews listening for the
all clear call.
Moving across the hill
another fire holding tree
to tip.
Taking out a snuff filled
tin... pausing to take a dip.
The faller protecting others
from the hazards of the snags.
Face to face with natures entities
in a deadly game of tag.
Oliver |
| 7/29 |
CA-MMU-Telegraph Fire (near Yosemite): <snip 10 sentences... Ab.>
Why does Cal Fire keep their maps secret and the feds post them openly?
Scrape
The state is reporting the Telegraph fire here:
www.fire.ca.gov/index_incidents_others.php Oh look, new map up now... (Inciweb
is a fed reporting site. Sometimes it's down too.) There have been a number
of requests for a briefing map for the Telegraph, showing division/branch
breaks. etc. If someone has a digitized version, we'll post it. Ab. |
| 7/29 |
My Friends,
One recent poster said regarding fire behavior prognostication/science: "it is a
developing science with no crystal balls". Of course I cannot argue that Fire
Behavior Science is still developing as it always has but you just cannot deny
the many, many years of education and experience that most Fire Behavior
Analysts have behind them. The Fire Behavior Analyst position has the toughest
education curriculum and the most rigid experience requirements in this wildland
firefighting business. Folks still doing FBAN, and there are few, need to always
be completely on top of their game and exercising their education, their many
years, and above all the graveness of their position as it relates to
firefighter safety. Most, if not all, are.
My heart goes out to the family and friends of Chief Packer. Thank the Almighty
for Vickie and the WFF for helping to somehow soften this horrible blow to all
of us.
OFBA |
| 7/29 |
"I get almost embarrassed when people make issues about bravery - I guess
I don't see firefighting in the same light that outsiders do. There are
risks, but the risks are just something I live with. when things are going a
bit sideways, when they get a little dicey, I get excited instead of scared.
After 23 years of doing this I still love feeling the edge. I still don't
think I'll ever go off it. People like me don't die. We're too experienced,
our judgment is sound, and as supervisors we are less often in the way of
danger. Or if we are in the way of danger, we always know how far we can we
can move from safety and still make it back."
WTF????
Blue
Blue, I think he meant this as an assumption he has had about himself and
those he sees as similar in KSAs to himself. You have to admit, it's a rude
awakening when you find out that when fire behaves badly or you've missed some
cue, sh** happens to the best, even to excellent, highly trained and experienced
firefighters. Reality Check of our human limitations! Risks must be consciously
evaluated and re-evaluated... situation by situation... Ab. |
| 7/29 |
From Firescribe: Loved ones mourn fallen East Pierce fire chief
by Mike Archbold
www.thenewstribune.com/331/story/426920.html
A tight-knit family of East Pierce firefighters remembers Dan Packer as a man
of compassion and strength.
As the shock of losing one of Pierce County’s most respected and well-liked fire
chiefs in a California wildland fire took hold, Dan Packer’s fellow firefighters
came together in grief Monday.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Air tanker drops in wildfires are often just for show
By Julie Cart and Bettina Boxall, Los Angeles Times Staff Writers, Second of
five parts, July 29, 2008
www.latimes.com/news/local/politics/cal/la-me-wildfires29-2008jul29,0,3486219.story
The bulky aircraft are reassuring sights to those in harm's way, but their
use can be a needless and expensive exercise to appease politicians. Fire
officials call them 'CNN drops.' |
| 7/29 |
older discussion regarding meteorologists: I was on assignment and didn't see
the discussion regarding meteorologists until just now. The role of the Storm
Prediction Center should not be confused with the role of the local forecast
office or incident meteorologist.
The Storm center provides the big-picture analysis, somewhat like
intelligence at NIFC provides us the big picture
of the wildland fire world. You would not make an on-the-ground decision for
your division based on NIFC data. Keep in mind too, that the local forecast
office is also looking fairly big-picture because they are preparing products
that meet the needs of Joe who wants to go sailing today as well as you who are
out on the fireline. Their spot-weather-forecasts come closer, but the IMET on
the ground is much closer.
The final safety comes in using the fire-line weather observations tied with
the thresholds established in the pocket cards PLUS gaining local knowledge from
those who regularly work with fire in your area. Most of the IMETs I've worked
with have been great, and understand the vital safety information that they are
providing. Realize too, that there is still plenty to be learned and understood
about weather, just as we still have plenty to learn and understand about fire
behavior -- it is a developing science with no crystal balls.
Still out there as an AD ... |
| 7/29 |
North Bay FC:
Your post about the Federal Gov't "obligation" to protect private lands contains
some inaccurate statements. You are correct that the Federal Government is not
subject to state or local taxes; however, it does provide payments directly to
states and counties in lieu of taxes, known as the PLIT program (payment in lieu
of taxes.) For instance, the state of Idaho received nearly $16 million in 2008
from the Feds for the lands held by various agencies. (For a county by county
breakdown, see the DOI website here:
www.nbc.gov/pilt/pilt/search.cfm)
Furthermore, any industry that takes place on Dept of Interior lands is subject
to revenue sharing under the Refuge Revenue Sharing Act of 1935 (and similar
laws for the Dept of Agriculture.) A quick search shows that the states of
Wyoming and Nebraska received almost $240 Million from the BLM alone 1999. (WY
and NE are organized in one district.)
So while there may not be any direct taxation, it's incorrect to say that state
and local governments get "no local tax revenue" from federal lands.
JerseyBoy |
| 7/28 |
To lay rumors to rest on the Panther Fire burnover. To the best of
my knowledge: There were only 2 people involved. Both were male. Dan Packer
died. The other firefighter was not physically injured. Thus, there is no
firefighter in a burn unit somewhere.
That's it. Ab. |
| 7/28 |
Ab,
Everyone has their 1st amendment right.
However, I agree that we need to put aside who pays for structure
protection, p to p and all that stuff and take a short pause.
Letterman
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
From R-5 RO.
Subject: Firefighter Fatality Memorial
To: All Region 5 Employees
In the past three days, the Region has suffered two tragic accidents that
resulted in the loss of two firefighters, Andrew Palmer and Daniel Packer.
Firefighter Palmer was from the Olympic National Park and was assigned to the
Iron Mt. Alps Fire Complex on the Shasta-Trinity National Forest. He was struck
by a falling tree and died as a result of his injuries on July 25, 2008. Chief
Packer was a division supervisor from the Eastern Pierce County Fire Department.
He died July 26, 2008 in a fire entrapment on the Panther Fire on the Klamath
National Forest.
Flags are to be flown at half staff, and employees are authorized to wear a
black mourning strip on the Forest Service badge in memory of Firefighter Palmer
and Chief Packer thru August 2.
I want to express my sympathy to the families, friends, and coworkers of the
firefighters we have lost. These tragic losses serve as reminders of the
hazardous work we engage in as we fight wildland fires. Please take time to
assess your individual preparedness, but also look out for one another so we can
all complete our work safely.
/s/ James M. Pena (for) Randy Moore, Regional Forester |
| 7/28 |
Important standards: Interim NWCG Minimum Standards for Incident Emergency
Medical Services: hotlist thread
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/showthread.php?p=27034
NWCG Standards for Burn Injuries: hotlist thread
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/showthread.php?t=897 |
| 7/28 |
I haven’t written much here in a long time, but I still check in now and again.
I felt I needed to share this.
Dan and I worked together on many fires, in fact he was the one who signed my
task book as Division Supervisor. When he did, he said something about me being
more qualified than he was - but that wasn't a reflection of his abilities but
of his modesty. He was a great man on the line. He always listened, he made sure
people were comfortable with was asked of them, he wanted their input and he
stood up for the firefighters working for him. He never struck me as someone who
was taking inordinate risks or someone who lacked an awareness of the situation
around him.
I guess that is what is so shocking about his death - I just can't see him
making a decision that would turn so bad.
I get almost embarrassed when people make issues about bravery - I guess I don't
see firefighting in the same light that outsiders do. There are risks, but the
risks are just something I live with. when things are going a bit sideways, when
they get a little dicey, I get excited instead of scared. After 23 years of
doing this I still love feeling the edge. I still don't think I'll ever go off
it. People like me don't die. We're too experienced, our judgment is sound, and
as supervisors we are less often in the way of danger. Or if we are in the way
of danger, we always know how far we can we can move from safety and still make
it back.
Dan was about my age. His career has been similar to mine, and we have learned
from each other. He was someone I both admired and liked very much. My loss of
him as a friend is nothing compared to the loss his department has suffered of
one of the great leaders, and that too is nothing compared to the loss his
family most feel. Dan loved his job, but he loved his family even more.
Some men can't be replaced. Only remembered.
Islander |
| 7/28 |
First- my condolences to the families and our entire extended fire
family. The losses are felt
throughout the country and it is a sad day.
North Bay FC-
You state there are no local taxes brought in by federal lands. I
don't know your background
but I am not sure how familiar you are
with the PILT- Payment in Lieu (sp?) of Taxes....
"Payments in Lieu of Taxes" (or PILT) are Federal payments to
local governments that help
offset losses in property taxes due to
nontaxable Federal lands within their boundaries. The
key law that
implements the payments is Public Law 94-565, dated October 20,
1976. This
law was rewritten and amended by Public Law 97-258 on
September 13, 1982 and codified
at
Chapter 69, Title 31 of the United States Code.
The Law recognizes that the inability of
local governments to
collect property taxes on Federally-owned land can create a
financial
impact.
(www.doi.gov/pilt/summary.html)
I don't know about Department of Ag but I know with DOI, the feds
do recognize the local
tax situation and try and do the right thing.
take care out there and stay safe,
GISgirl |
| 7/28 |
Please take a moment today and remember the members of Lassen NF Engine 11 who
lost their lives suppressing the Stanza Fire the morning of July 28th . Steve,
Heather and John...
Six years gone now are an outstanding leader, a great friend and a fine young
man. With the events of the last few days making room in our hearts for any more
sorrow hard to find, loosing touch with the past dooms us to repeat it. Perhaps
the pain of loss will give us the strength to do what is necessary to save our
own lives or the life of another. Awareness is our finest tool to prevent
mishaps. I took the
included photograph as a tribute to the Engine 11 fellas but in reality it
must be a tribute to all those who have left us on the lines.
Rob
Thanks, Rob, their loss touched me greatly as well. I added your photo to
their tribute page. Ab. |
| 7/28 |
Why should the Federal Govt. pay to protect private structures from fires
burning on Federal lands? The Federal answer seems to be “we shouldn’t” and it
is the local agencies responsibility. In a recent post the comparison was made
that if a warehouse was burning the local fire department protects adjacent
buildings.
There are two reasons that the Federal Govt. should continue to pay for
reasonable protection on developed private lands;
First: The private land owner pays federal taxes, as do the property owners
adjacent to the burning warehouse pay local taxes, and should probably get
something for that. The enormous cost to provide structure protection to a small
community is so far beyond the ability to pay the result would be many small
communities will burn to the ground. Think that might make a few headlines and
catch the attention of the Politicians in Washington? It is also important to
note that Federal Land brings in NO local tax revenue.
Second: By far the most important reason is that through land use and management
decisions, including firefighting guidelines, and staffing shortages, the
ability to quickly and effectively attack and contain many fires in Federal
Lands have been greatly diminished. When lightning starts a fire in the
wilderness area established after the community was founded, can the local
community take dozers in and extinguish the fire to protect their community? Or
must they weight sometimes weeks for the fire to burn to their property because
MIST is required even when burning conditions exceed MIST tactical restrictions?
Structure protection is in place for days or weeks due to land use policy, why
should locals pay for the policy of the land owner?
As is always the case, there is usually merit to both sides of the argument. Yes
Local Govt. must step up to the plate and enforce reasonable fire safe standards
for existing and new development. There is defiantly a problem with “if it
burns, the feds will pay for protection” weather directly through incident costs
or FEMA reimbursements. However simply walking away from an established practice
and public expectation isn’t the answer. Not a lot of votes coming from
federally owned lands. I also think Casey hit the nail on the head regarding P
to P, the same methodology for pay needs to exist in all regions, and for all
Federal Firefighters (if you fight fire you are a firefighter regardless of
title) should see P to P.
North Bay FC |
| 7/28 |
Ab,
I just returned from Yreka where those involved in the Panther Fire have been
taken for debriefing. Two of our fallers were believed to be the last to have
contact with Mr. Packer as they were walking out a handline and he was scouting
up it. It was a difficult situation for them. However, I very much appreciate
the critical incident debriefing process that is taking place. It's an excellent
example of taking care of the people left behind.
As we're mentioning WFF and the incredible assistance Vicki and her crew provide
to firefighters and their families, I believe this is an appropriate and
critical time to emphasize that all state and federal agencies are required to
implement and manage programs to address employee injuries and fatalities. These
programs cost money and are tedious and demanding for those who administer them.
Some programs are administered well and fairly. And some are not. However, the
most important point here is that workers and their families have some sort of
safety net to help them get back into the saddle after an accident or death of a
worker, which is particularly important if that worker is the sole breadwinner
of the family.
Federal firefighters are so VERY fortunate to have Casey and the FWFSA to watch
their back and advocate for their rights. Other agencies have their unions and
employee reps. No agency would ever get away with putting an employee out on the
fireline without insurance coverage in case of injury of death. Most agencies
also provide added benefits to ramp up that coverage with employee participant
health/medical supplemental plans.
This isn't the case with agency AQM oversight of private sector operators. That
rigorous attention to worker safety nets has been ignored at the federal level
as it applies to private sector commercial timber fallers working on wildland
fires. This year, with the intense and early fire season in California, which
has created a chaotic resource mobilization headache for dispatch centers,
uncovered fallers have flowed into the wildland firefighting system unchecked.
Why? Because no one within the agencies is verifying valid worker compensation
coverage. Though some Faller Module operators are paying these premiums and
providing the ACTUAL coverage for their fallers as WE HAVE BEEN INSTRUCTED BY
THE FOREST SERVICE to do, there appears to be "special" operators who are held
to different standards, being allowed to act simply as brokers who pocket a
dispatch fee. This "fee" doesn't provide insurance coverage for the fallers, it
simply lines the pockets of the broker. This was the essence of my previous
message requesting what others thought about personal injury/fatality insurance
for commercial timber fallers working on fires.
Ah, you might say, "But those fallers get higher pay to cover themselves."
Really? The majority of fallers are so broke - especially right now - most live
paycheck to paycheck, with significant stretches of unemployment. With empty
bank accounts and their mortgage bills on the kitchen table, and food to
buy...and outrageous fuel prices that regularly add up to hundreds of dollars a
month just to get to work and run their saws, exactly how much might you think
is set aside for a medical emergency or fatality? I would estimate perhaps 1 in
50 fallers has any type of health or medical coverage, and those that carry an
"if/any" insurance policy most often opt out (meaning they don't cover
themselves as a single operator) just to get as much needed cash in their
pockets as they can. They're broke. It's a classic dilemma for them. They have
to feed their families NOW. Pay their mortgages NOW. Put fuel in their trucks so
they can go to work NOW (if work is actually available.)
So, there's the dilemma...and there is the opportunity for exploitation of the
fallers' situation - both by agencies and by unscrupulous operators. Worker
compensation coverage (and all health/medical coverage) is expensive. The
government has said consistently over the past three years that the Faller
Module program - while fire managers in the field say it is a huge improvement
over the old AD Faller hiring program - is too expensive. However, what they are
not recognizing is that it is the worker compensation part of the DIRECT COSTS
that increases the price to the threshold of "too expensive." It is too
convenient for the agency to turn the other way and allow operators to slither
through a loop hole such as providing an "if/any" worker compensation
certificate as proof of coverage, but then not actually providing the coverage
for fallers. That is what is happening right now in California. And that is
something that needs to be addressed by the same agency that incorporates worker
safety and insurance coverage for its own employees. Let's see some
accountability. Let's see the INTENT of the worker coverage law enforced rather
than the LETTER.
The bottom line is - everyone's families need to be taken care of in times of
tragedy, not just those working for an agency. Thanks to Vicki and her crew, WFF
is colorblind and recognizes no differentiation between agency and private
sector firefighter. They are a blessing to us all, and deserve all our our
financial support. Now, it's time for R-5 to step to the plate and do the
responsible thing. If not, there are other oversight agencies that will.
Shari Downhill
Northwest Timber Fallers |
| 7/28 |
From Tom Harbour: This Sunday evening is a time of reflection for me. The
emotion is
sadness, the thoughts are contemplative. It is surely a time to think.
Our minds are our greatest assets.
Given the wildland fire situation we are and will be facing the next couple
months, and the stresses which will surely continue, my mind turns to those
concepts we espouse in operational risk management. Leadership will come
from the exercise of correct principles. We'll continue to look to the
principles of accountability, integrity, team work, and open/continuous
communication. We'll identify hazards, risks, and mitigations. We'll
remember the key concepts of the operational risk management approach the
Chief endorsed.
-accept risk only when benefits outweigh risks
-accept no unnecessary risk
-anticipate and manage risk
-make risk decisions at the right level
As we practice these principles at beginner to advanced levels, at first
line to upper line supervisors, at type 5 to type 1 complexity, we'll be
good.
Lets take time to honor those who have perished, to continually improve,
and to recommit ourselves to supporting one another.
Tom |
| 7/28 |
Ice Capping: I have been unable to find a definition. I see reference to it
from
time to time. Might this be an appropriate entry for the Glossary?
Assuming it rains again someday, and somebody has time for something
as mundane as a glossary...
My deepest condolences on the loss of the two Washington
firefighters. First time this site made me cry. What a pitiless
thing, fire.
--Shellie Taylor
Cobb Mountain, Lake County, CA
Check this thread:
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/showthread.php?p=26993 (Thanks Jumper553, I
couldn't find it.) Ab. |
| 7/28 |
From the Panther Fire
Yesterday afternoon firefighters and the Siskiyou County Sheriff worked their
way into the Panther Fire accident site. At approximately 1930, Dan Packer of
East Pierce Fire and Rescue was met at the intersection of Hwy 96 and
Independence Bridge north of Orleans by an Engine from the Six Rivers NF. He was
escorted to Happy Camp and then accompanied to Yreka by an Engine from the
Klamath NF as the first leg of his journey back to Washington State. |
| 7/27 |
Our grievances are now placed on the back-burner as we join together as an
interagency community to grieve the passing of our brothers.
When I woke up this morning, I started thinking about the Esperanza Fire. Out of
the shock of Esperanza came the moment I was proudest of my agency, the Forest
Service.
I was reminded this morning about the honorable work of CIIMT #1 lead by Don
Feser back in Oct and Nov of 2006. While CAL FIRE did a great job suppressing
the Esperanza, CIIMT #1 was asked to provide support and begin the healing
process for the families and for all of us. The work they performed was
unequaled in any single event in Forest Service history.
I remember listening to the stories from my friends on CIIMT #1 when they came
home. I think back now and those stories we heard was a way for them to release
the emotions and it helped them heal.
Now CIIMT #1 is heading to the Panther Fire. The great leader Don Feser has
since retired, however they’re in good hands with McGowan and Hawkins. We wish
them well on this new assignment.
I remember great speeches the day of the Esperanza Memorial. The words of Walker
and Detrich will never be forgotten and echo in our minds even today. The words
that stuck with me the most that afternoon came from the Forest Service National
Director for FAM Tom Harbour. Tom looked around and referenced the presence of
an angel. An angel and organization who are committed to caring. Tom was right,
that angel, our angel is Vicki Minor, Executive Director of the Wildland
Firefighter Foundation.
www.wffoundation.org
ms |
| 7/27 |
This info is coming in from firefighters in WA and CA: Washington state fire
chief believed dead in California blaze
www.komonews.com/news/25963444.html
REDDING, Calif. - A second Washington state firefighter is believed to have
perished Saturday while battling a Northern California wildfire, officials said.
Daniel Packer, chief of East Pierce Fire & Rescue and past president of the
Washington Fire Chiefs, was reported missing Saturday afternoon while working on
the Panther Fire south of Happy Camp in Siskiyou County, and is presumed dead.
"He (Packer) is missing, but we have not confirmed that he is dead," said
Russ McCallion, battalion chief with East Pierce Fire & Rescue.
However, the U.S. Forest Service confirmed that a second firefighter has
died, without releasing the identity. (more at link)
Our condolences to family, friends and co-workers. I know from what
several of our community have said that he was a well known and much respected
chief in the state. Please let us know about services. Ab. |
| 7/27 |
Shari and Casey:
Excellent advice for working near snags !
Having experienced a near miss while working with a snag, all's I can say is
never for a moment let your guard down. Even the small snags are profoundly
dangerous and can come down, or drop materials without so much as a whisper
of warning !!!
- Always maintain a high level of Situational Awareness around snags, Post
experienced lookouts double the distance the perimeter of any where the
snag can possibly fall.
- Exercise extra care when working near trees that have been burning a
long
time and / or show signs of rot or deterioration.
- Be aware that even without "widowmakers" , snags can and do drop
materials,
or break off segments without warning.
- If material has fallen from a snag previously, it is an indicator that
the
snag is weak and may drop more material at any time !
- Limit personnel from working the snag hazard area.
I'm sure there is much more information to cover regarding snags, I just
wanted to share a few items I had, and hopefully help keep the folks out
there safe!
My sincere condolences to the Palmer family.
Pappy '81 (not the original) |
| 7/27 |
NWCG has approved a NATIONAL burn injury standard. The standard was issued July
11, 2008. Please forward and share this standard with the field as it has not
had wide dissemination.
With few minor exceptions in wording, it has all of the major recommendations
from the collaborative groups working on it... both in the forefront and behind
the scenes.
Standard Attached (46 K pdf file).
NoNameThanks to those who have continued to press for this behind the
scenes. Thanks also to the others who stepped up to set it into "official"
motion. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Community. We need some good thoughts / prayers for a firefighter
who has died on the CA-KNF-Panther Fire and one who may have gotten taken to the hospital.
More info is here:
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/showthread.php?t=5978
No doubt more to come. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
To the Families, You don't know me, but you are in my prayers and thoughts. I
too, used to be on the line... and above it most of the time. Nobody but those
who have experienced the conditions we work in know what is real, and even then,
we question the reality of it all at times. When nature throws its worst at us,
only then does the very best come out in us. We are brothers and sisters. We are
family. Our uniforms and badges mean nothing... we all look the same at the end
of the day. We are one in the "good fight" for a greater cause.
As you are the families of those "on the line", you are a big part of the circle
of our lives. We think of you, we miss you, we honor you in doing what we do.
There is no greater love than for a human being than to give their life for
another. You should be honored. You raised us to be the individuals we are. You
taught us honor and respect. You taught us charity and to care for those who
could not do for themselves. You taught us unconditional love beyond ourselves.
You raised a hero.
We take our licks, but keep on ticking. We go without, so you can have. We give
everything we have, so that you can have everything. We spend a lot of lonely
nights, babysitting a fire line, on the side of a mountain hundreds of miles
away from home. The silence is deafening, broken only by the sound of our own
heartbeat and an occasional rabbit. It's these times we think of you. We think
about why we do what we do. God only knows the thoughts that occupy our minds. A
hundred different things occupy our thoughts in a brief few moments. Things
change, sometimes in a heartbeat.
My Grandpa used to say that God only takes the good ones. I've spent many times
wondering if this was so. I've been in many situations where I thought I'd find
out real quick. One thing I've learned over the years, is that you don't
question the ultimate authority. The reasoning is beyond human comprehension. I
do know for a fact, that angels do indeed wear Nomex! When it's my time, I'm
ready to go. I have no regrets. I've given everything I could give and I only
wish I could have given more. I dream of a day when words like these never have
to be written. Rejoice in the fact that your sons and daughters, brothers and
sisters, fathers and mothers, husbands and wives, are taking a stand for
something that eclipses all time. They are firefighters, heroes, and angels.
Sometimes real life gets in the way of what we perceive as "real life". I've
missed parties, graduations, birthdays, and anniversaries. My 40th B-day was
spent filling tankers from a hydrant in rural Nebraska. I didn't care... this
was what I did. Not just a job (actually, a volunteer)... but the greatest
adventure I could ever have with the greatest people to share it with. It's
funny, my hand was still wrapped in gauze from an accident at work... but I was
there pumping water for the team. You can't imagine the feeling of contributing
to the cause... even when you're not supposed to be. Yup, shame on me, but
hey.... I'm a firefighter, these things don't slow us down. We always give until
someone says we can't give anymore, then we go and keep giving... THAT WILL
NEVER END. Again, that's who we are and what we do.
My thoughts and prayers are with you, wherever you may be. Whether enjoying a
family BBQ on a summer night or sitting on a fire line, a hundred miles away
from home. You are never far away from me. You see, it doesn't matter whether
I'm retired or active... I'm on your crew... right now. Whether you are on the
ground or in the air... I'm there too. Some call it a "brotherhood", I prefer
"Family". We're all in this together, let's keep trying to make a difference. To
be a bit sappy, I'd like to use a line from a really sappy movie, "NEVER GIVE
UP... NEVER SURRENDER"!
Embracing each and everyone of you!
Feeding the Squirrels in Boise!
Well said my friend. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
By
U.S. Forest Service Chief Abigail Kimbell
Loss of firefighter Andrew Palmer
Forest Service Press Conference
July 26, 2008
“Thanks for joining us here today. Today I’ve been here in Redding, Calif.
meeting with local Forest Service officials. We’ve been focusing on the
unprecedented scope of fire here in northern California, which have become more
devastating with the tragic loss of Andrew Palmer, of Port Townsend, Wash., an
18 year old firefighter. Palmer was with the Olympic National Park in Washington
state and his life was tragically cut short just yesterday afternoon.
“The wildland fire community is a very large organization, but in many ways it
resembles a family. The loss of any member of the firefighting family has a
dramatic affect on all of those who fight fire, who are involved in fire
management and who work for the agency. The commitment to society demonstrated
by Andrew Palmer – through his dedication and courage – will live on in the
hearts and minds of his colleagues all throughout the fire community. To the
Palmer family my heart goes out to you. I am so sorry for your loss.
“People are our most valuable resource and we remain committed to the safety of
our firefighters. We cannot forget that there are still 12,000 firefighters
continuing to work to suppress fires here in California. We’ve made great
progress but much remains to be done.
“Our interagency fire teams develop strategies for fighting a fire. Fire
managers continue to consider fire behavior, weather forecasts, terrain,
accessibility and proximity to communities when considering fire suppression
strategies.
“In spite of the extremely difficult terrain, in this part of the world, crews
on these fires have done an extraordinary job. The terrain is difficult and
unforgiving.
“We will really miss Andrew Palmer.
“Crews are using burnouts and other indirect firefighting techniques because of
the inaccessible, rugged terrain and other hazards keeping them from the fire
edge. We must consider firefighter safety in all of our tactical decisions.
Firefighter and public safety will remain our number one concern.
“As I close, I ask that you keep Andrew, his family, his friends and co-workers
in your thoughts and prayers. As tradition, firefighters will wear black bands
around their service badge and I am asking all Forest Service officers to lower
their flags to half-mast beginning today in remembrance of Andrew.”
# |
| 7/26 |
Ab, This is regarding Jarred Johnson:
The accident is being investigated, and as such, preliminary information is
subject to change.
What we know for certain....is that this accident occurred in a wilderness
area; his crew stabilized, medivac'd and transported him within an hour and
were informed by late evening that he would be alright.
Jarred's "broken" vertebrae...is a compression, hairline fracture to his
thoracic region (between the shoulder blades).
He will be fitted with a brace for his torso within the next few days, to
stabilize the injury site, and facilitate healing.
To avoid confusion and misinformation, I think we need to clarify a strange
and sad coincidence:
Jarred's brother is a member of the Olympic National Park crew who lost
their Firefighter, Andrew Palmer, yesterday.
These incidents appear to have occurred within hours of one another.
It must have been a tremendous, and overwhelming day for the Johnson and
Palmer families, as it was for our entire fire community.
I praise your site for allowing privacy for the families and friends prior
to confirmed notification.
Please know that these families are sustained by the strength of your
support...and WFF, of course.
It does seem that at times like these, we are not merely a fire service,
but a service FOR one another.....when an accident occurs.
Training gives the skills and circumstance gives you the opportunity, but
knowledge gives you the confidence to take action.
No one does this job alone, together we take care of one another.
Thanks Ab.
R5Vet FF
Thanks for the clarification. Good job and carry on. We do support each
other. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Photo of Andy Palmer. Our best to his family. They know they are not
alone in their grief. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
AB & All:
We too at the FWFSA would like to offer our most heartfelt condolences to
Andrew's
family, friends & co-workers for his tragic loss on the Iron Complex.
Shari has once again offered common sense but nonetheless insightful guidance on
the
issue of snags. Simply, they kill. It doesn't matter if it's a wildfire or an
RX, they kill.
We wish all of you on the lines not only a safe incident but a safe season.
Please take
care of each other and watch out for each other.
Casey |
| 7/26 |
There was another falling accident yesterday in R6.
Jarred Johnson was hit by a widowmaker and was Life Flighted to
Wenatchee. He has a broken vertebrae, but this morning has feeling in his
extremities which is a very good sign. He'll likely be in the hospital for
2-3 weeks and in a body cast for longer. (The WFF -- with our donations --
is willing to pick up the cost of lodging and car rental for Jarred's folks and his
brother.) Mellie
The WFF and the wildland firefighting community is supporting Jarred and his
family in ways that most could not imagine.
Our prayers for a speedy recovery.
Please be safe All. Hug your loved ones. Support the WFF. It's our safety
net.
Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Abs...The USFS is drawing criticism for the poor air quality in the Northern
Sacramento Valley ...again.
The fire is directed toward the burnouts on USFS fires, but CalFire certainly
did their share of causing the pollution.
www.redding.com/news/2008/jul/26/burnouts-criticized/
The June Fire siege resulted in fires that lasted longer than any in the history
of the Shasta Unit of CalFire. While some of that may be blamed on the sheer
number of fires, but some of the criticism must be directed to the Agency's
handling of those fires.
In the case of the USFS fires, again, there were a ton of starts, but Agency
policy has also contributed to the proliferation of smoke. At what time does
public health and well being override the desire for a "light hand on the land?"
Containment for some of the USFS fires is not predicted until mid August or
later.
viejo |
| 7/26 |
From this morning's Iron Complex News Update Firefighter Andrew Palmer, of the
Olympic National Park, received multiple injuries yesterday while working on the
Eagle fire. He passed away while being transported to Redding, California. A
fund will be established by the Wildland Firefighter Foundation in Andrew’s
name. The foundation is online at
http://wffoundation.org/
and can be contacted by calling 877-336-2950. |
| 7/26 |
Observing Snag Felling Ab,
We realize that an investigation is underway on the Iron Complex, and that will
likely take some time to complete. However, after talking with fallers on that
incident, and taking into consideration what many other fallers have experienced
this season on wildland fire incidents I believe that a strong message should go
out concerning the desire to observe snag felling.
On several occasions, when our fallers were given the "all clear" sign, they
discovered their cutting areas were, in fact, not completely clear of observers
within harms way. One faller team even had to flush firefighters out of the
nearby brush, and only detected them because their radio made some noise. This
was AFTER the fallers were told the area was clear.
It's not only the snag being cut that can cause problems, but every tree within
range of the target tree, because of the domino effect, secondary limb breakage,
or ground rolling. These big snags in Northern California are not only huge, but
extremely unstable for various reasons. Even seasoned commercial fallers with
decades of saw time at the stump are having trouble with them. So, the message
is, STAY CLEAR.... STAY AWAY...LISTEN AND ABIDE BY CLEAR OUT INSTRUCTIONS FROM
THE FALLERS, FALLER BOSSES & TASK FORCE UNIT LEADERS. These fallers have enough
on their minds without worrying that someone's hiding in the bushes just to see
a tree go down.
NOTE: This message is not intended to comment on the Iron Complex
fatality specifically, but to hopefully send a message to agency supervisors in
the field. When you think your people are far enough away from a snag to assure
their safety - double that distance again... and don't forget to look in the
bushes for stow aways.
Shari Downhill
I'm posting this important safety message. I observed a near miss (not on
a fire) this summer and falling safety can't be stressed too much. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Ab,
A number of our fallers called in early this morning after they heard the tragic
news about Andrew in various morning briefings across the region. I want to pass
on their condolences. It’s news that disturbs us all, and reminds us that we
should treasure each day we have with one another. Our thoughts and support go
to the young man’s family. Thank goodness for Vicki and the WFF.Shari
Downhill
It was good to hear back from Burk last night that the WFF was "on it".
Beyond condolences, my first inclination is "what can I do to help?"
The Wildland Firefighter
Foundation certainly is a safety net for all of us when things go bad.
Firefighting is an inherently dangerous profession. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Casey,
Thanks for your response. Somehow I think we are getting tangled up here on what
the intent was with my original post on this subject, probably my fault not
yours. What I simply wanted to know was how many wild land firefighting
organizations of any kind, outside of California are getting portal to portal. I
was not wanting to pass any judgment on the pro and cons and who deserves what,
I just wanted to know who was getting portal to portal. Again, I was only
interested in entities outside of California.
We can discuss the municipal/wildland deal and probably not come to agreement.
This is and has for a long time been a situation that frustrates me. Why are the
feds paying municipal fire departments for structure protection? I personally
believe it is their responsibility and not the wild land agencies. If the fire
is downtown in a warehouse they protect adjacent structures. So why does the
same not apply when structures are threatened by wild fire? Let the
municipalities step up and bite the bullet. That is basically where I am on the
subject. Of course the feds would just turn around and end up reimbursing them.
I can't count how many incidents I have been on over the years where one of the
first things done was to get the disaster declaration approved so the feds would
pick up most of the bill, which in essence opened up the purse strings. But that
is another subject.Joy Juice was a poor choice of words on my part, sorry
about that.
I don't think you answered my question regarding if Cal Fire was not getting
portal to portal would it be an issue? I realize this goes back a long way in
time, but is it not what made portal to portal an issue? Again, not wanting to
debate the merits of portal to portal, I think it would be great if we were all
getting portal to portal.
the cynic |
| 7/26 |
A couple of shots from a burning operation near Shasta lake, 01 July 2008.
Crew name unavailable.
Al Henkle
Thanks, some CalFire firefighters. I put them on the
Engines 20
photo page. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Here are a few photos from the ICP while a burning operation was in progress
to protect basecamp for the Iron Complex. ~ Troy VaughnThanks, very nice
flames. I put them on the
Fires 38
photo page. One of those could be a contender for the 2009 Wildlandfire
Calendar. Ab. |
| 7/26 |
Casey and Cynic;
Remember when talking about portal to portal and CALFIRE, we are only talking
about Fire Fighters through Battalion Chief who get PP.
Many Division/Assistant chiefs, and Deputy Chiefs, Foresters, Warehouse folks (FLOs),
Communication Operators (dispatchers), and office support staff DO NOT get
Portal to Portal. They get pillow to pillow, just like all their friends in
USDA-FS and DOI individuals get.
Now FFs to BCs are the folks down in the trenches, but consider that the folks
that Bargaining unit 8 also represents, foresters, forestry technicians,
forestry assistants, forestry logistics officers, forestry trainees, and
forestry aids, and Air operations officers work a basic 40 hr week, either 5 8’s
or 4 10’s. Pillow to Pillow for them as well.
And a lot of these people are also on large incidents, filling critical ICS
roles on teams and on incidents. Or working along side a FF, or FAE or Captain
that is getting P to P, doing the same job in fire camp, or might be working for
that FLO or Forester who is getting pillow to pillow. However those job
positions did get a 3% raise in 06 just for them.
So even within CALFIRE and California Bargaining unit 8, there is pay disparity.
But keep in mind, the fire suppression personnel gave up a pay raise to get
their Portal to Portal. So it did not come free to them.
So if Casey wins the Portal to Portal, and it sounds like things are looking up,
someone representing those agencies and OPM are going to have to figure out WHO
gets Portal to Portal and who does not. If Casey gets P to P for everyone
assigned to an ongoing incident, he has more than earned his pay. But if OPM
says only line personnel get P to P, that may make it hard for the “militia” to
answer their phones.
JustthinkingoutloadHaw Haw, "earn his pay" is an amusing phrase in this
instance. Casey gets paid almost nothing. He's powered by the "joy juice". Ab. |
| 7/25 |
Sad news. A National Park Service firefighter has been killed on the Iron
Complex.
www.wildlandfire.com/hotlist/forumdisplay.php?f=2
Our thoughts and prayers are with the family, friends and fellow
firefighters. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Dear Cynic:
I believe the term "portal to portal" may mean different things to different
people. It is a concept of compensation simply meaning you get paid from the
time you arrive at work until the time you go home.
The "concept" of portal to portal is primarily used for a shift period of 24
hours or more. Most paid, professional firefighters who work shift increments of
24 hrs are paid for a 24 hour shift inclusive of meal & sleep periods.
The Office of Personnel Management has determined that a firefighter average
work week is 53 hours. Some obviously work more per week, others less. However
the term portal to portal, as in compensating these employees for all time while
on duty may take a different meaning on a wildfire incident simply because the
federal wildland firefighters usually work a 40 hour work week as compared to a
state or local firefighter that normally work shifts of 24 hours at a time.
As an example, if you are a paid, profession municipal firefighter from
California working a normal duty shift of 24 hrs and you are sent on a wildfire
assignment that exceeds 24 hours, you are paid for a full 24 hrs at a salary
rate that is more often than not significantly higher than your federal
counterpart on the assignment whether you are on the line or in fire camp
resting, showering, eating etc. If the federal government, such as a land
management agency is picking up the cost of you as a resource, that federal
Agency will also pay your department a 17% administrative fee, plus backfill
costs to cover your position. Additionally, as has been discussed here with
great passion, many non-federal resources are housed in hotels and motels at
federal expense.
On the other hand, if you are a federal wildland firefighter from any of the
five federal land management agencies -- i.e. Forest Service, National Park
Service, Bureau of Land Management, Bureau of Indian Affairs and Fish & Wildlife
-- you normally work an 8 hour day. When you are sent on a wildfire assignment
which may be 24 hours or longer, you are only paid for a maximum of 16 hours in
any 24 hour period. The other 8 hours or more in that 24 hour period are not
compensated for, despite the fact that your employer is paying non-federal
resources for the full 24 hours. Additionally, more often than not, you'll be in
a tent or sleeping on the ground.
Recently time keepers have been trying to cut even the compensated hours of
federal firefighters while ignoring the 24 hours of pay for non-federal
firefighters.
The concept of portal to portal as applied to federal wildland firefighters is
very simple and basic. If you are dispatched to an emergency incident that
exceeds 24 hours, you are paid for all hours on the assignment whether you are
on the line, eating, sleeping etc.
Much of the debate around portal to portal for federal wildland firefighters
from the firefighter's perspective can be found in language from the Office of
Personnel Management which, in simplified terms, says that if you are bound to a
location in an official capacity and cannot utilize your "free time" as you
would normally be able to (for instance being in a fire camp in a remote area of
the country for up to 2 weeks or more) than such time is compensable under FLSA.
Portal to portal for federal wildland firefighters would not provide true pay
parity for federal wildland firefighters with those non-federal resources that
make significantly more. However, knowing that you would be compensated using
the same methodology as everyone else on the assignment would be a huge benefit
to the retention problems facing the federal agencies. The obvious frustration
among federal firefighters, especially in the West is that their employer is
paying others for a full 24 hours plus additional costs while taking their own
employees off the clock, usually putting them in the dirt or in tents, while
many non-federal firefighters are housed in better accommodations.
These are facts. There is no disrespect towards the non-federal resources, but
we simply feel that the concept of equal pay for equal work, at least in the
methodology of compensation is way overdue in the federal sector.
Respectfully,
Casey Judd
Business Manager
FWFSA |
| 7/24 |
Returned home from another assignment and an update for all:
Ryan was fully cleared to full duty by the burn center in San Francisco on
7/11 after suffering second degree burns to both feet on 6/4 at the Jungle
Fire in Arizona. He returned to the crew on 7/12 at the Ukonom Complex in
Northern California in good spirits and ready to work. We returned home on
7/23 and he is showing no after effects or issues with his injuries after
working a number of demanding fire shifts in very difficult terrain.
All-in-all, no major issues were encountered during his recovery or his
treatment. Thanks for the assistance from everyone who helped out Ryan and
the crew during this event. Please feel free to forward this to anyone you
see fit to close this loop.
Steve Shaw
Superintendent, Diamond Mountain IHCGood news. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Some nice photos of lightning, the first monsoon show near Phoenix AZ on June
6, 2008. Mark G is the photographer. Also a pic of the Ethan Fire near Phoenix
after "another good afternoon run in the riverbed" around the same time.
Photos on
Fires 38
photo page. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Info on Ellreese -- Jimbo
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Subject: Fw: Character Reference - Ellreese Daniels - Letters of Support
Group - Here's a way to help Ellreese with a character reference letter.
Individually or as a group. __________________________
I just read that Judge Van Sickle will sentence Ellreese Daniels on August18,
2008. Before sentencing Ellreese, the families of the Thirtymile victims will
speak publically in court to the judge. It was brought to my attention that
character reference/letters in support of Ellreese may be sent to the judge
beforehand for him to also consider in determining Ellreese's sentence. Jail
time is a possibility. Although the good thing is the felony charges were
dropped by the plea bargain agreement; by not having a trial it also limits the
amount of information Judge Van Sickle has to consider when determining
Ellreese's sentence.
If you would like to submit a letter in support of Ellreese for the judge's
consideration, you can send it via Ellreese's attorney Tina Hunt at: Tina_ Hunt
(at sign) fd. org (take out spaces and add appropriate symbol)
I know Ellreese would be very appreciative of our support for him at this
critical time. Please feel free to send this message to others who have worked
with Ellreese or have knowledge of the strange twist in the Thirtymile fire
behavior.
Thank you!
Margi Peterson |
| 7/24 |
hey ab, here are some pics of the larson fire near coleville Ca. June of 07; and
two helo filling pics on the sleeping elephant fire from July of last year! mike
k Thanks, I put them on the
Fires 38
and
Helicopters 24 photo pages. Also posted a logo of the Fuego Tech Rangers off
the Angeles sent in by Anthony. It's on
Logos 14. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Process predicament?... or adding more to the plates of already overtaxed Area
Commanders, Type 1 ICs, and Type 2 ICs..... Noname
From NIFC FTP Site:
North Ops - Strategic Planning - Volume #1
Boise NIMO: June 22 - July 10, 2008
135 pp. - 3.1 MB PDF File
North Ops - Strategic Planning - Volume #2
Phoenix NIMO: July 10-21, 2008
149 pp. - 30.3 MB DOC File
Boise NIMO: The National Incident Management Organization (NIMO) Boise
Incident Management Team (IMT) was asked to develop concepts, review processes
and assist Northern California Operations (North Ops) and the NorCal
Multi-Agency Coordination (MAC) Group with providing support and coordination to
the incidents in northern California. Included within the attached report are
the project documents that support the following recommendations;
• Establish a 'Theater or Zone of Operations' management organization concept to
the extent possible.
• Establish and staff an aviation operations officer to handle the allocation
and reallocation of critical air resources from the GACC level.
• Implement the resource allocation / reallocation and 'Force Multiplier'
strategies.
• Implement the Fire Suppression Rehabilitation Strategy.
• Continue to use the Key Decision Log to capture critical decisions,
recommendations and thoughts.
• Develop, in consultation with the Line Officer Team in R-5, and implement a
mop-up strategy to ensure the incidents are not being required to implement
mopup standards that would engage fire suppression resources needed at other
incidents.
• Continue to utilize the ESF4 Lead, Cal-Fire, Phoenix Fire Department AHIMT and
FEMA personnel to support and coordinate the ordering, in processing and support
of the ESF4 resources.
• After the fire season ends, establish an interagency task force to review and
update, based on lessons learned, the established processes and procedures that
were enacted.
Phoenix NIMO: "The purpose of this Strategic Planning document is to
build upon the products and processes that the Boise NIMO had initiated and
implemented from June 22 to July 10, which is summarized in Operational Support:
Strategic Planning, Volume 1." |
| 7/24 |
Let's remember it's not just state and feds here- the county and local folks can
also get portal to portal and in CA that's a looooooong list:
Sac Metro, Kern Co, LA Co, San Bernardino Co, SD City, Ventura Co, LA City,
Bakersfield, etc.
By the way... any reason a DPRO position is still considered "mission critical"
in this day and age and a GISS is not? Thought that was an interesting omission
from the 2008 matrix that FS gal did such an awesome job on. Many IMTs now carry
GISS. Now don't get me wrong I <heart> the DPROs and always want one on my
fires, but c'mon people it's been 2 years- GISS is an ICS position not Tech Spec
and if you order a GIST it'll be UTFed forever (since it no longer exists).
</end rant>
Anyways if any of you fire people are going to be at the ESRI conference let me
know and we'll grab a beer (yes, Fire Geek you are already sharpied in).
GISGirl |
| 7/24 |
Ab,
Here are some photos of the Corral Fire on the California LMU. These were
taken when my engine was called to aid CALFIRE due to major spotting on 6/28/08.
That afternoon the fire had a thunder cell blow over. The fire gained 5,000
acres in less than four hours. A lot of crews had to pull off the lines to
safety zones due to erratic fire conditions.
Russell H
Thanks Russell. I put the photos of the plume on the
Fires 38
photo page. Photo of the firefighters on on the
Handcrews 23
photo page. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Ab,
These pictures were taken of the Cold Springs Fire on July 12-13. This fire
is on the Mt Adams district side of the Gifford Pinchot NF. Pictures by Steph S.
'Clean Air Steph'. 4 of the photos show the bug killed timber that's fueling the
fire.
-FireBill
Thanks FireBill. Readers, the photos were sent in on 7/16. Rather amazing
perspective, from that of a hiker. I put them on the
Fires 37 photo page. Ab. |
| 7/24 |
As far as I know, in R-6 (at least in Oregon) the only firefighters that are
normally being paid portal to portal, would be the county firefighters mobilized
under the states emergency conflagration system. If a strike team of Type-1
structure engines, from say Klamath Falls in Klamath County, gets ordered to
respond 2 hours north to the Bend area in Deschutes County for structure
protection, they are on portal to portal pay until they return home. It's
possible that there may also be some overhead positions occasionally being
filled using some of the county personnel that get portal to portal pay in R-6
too, but I can't confirm that.
Signed, Sprague |
| 7/24 |
Numbering engines (from the hotlist) Old green and gray guy.
You are correct about the engine /pump unit model numbering and the main
difference between the Mod 50 and 51 was that the crew was out side on the
50 and was in side the truck cab on the mod 51 (a LOT warmer in cold
weather!) Pumps where pretty much the same on both and better compartments
on the 51.
Old LPF (not so old if DOI has people with a average age of 105?)
He's referring to the last spreadsheet looking at attrition of aging
firefighters in firefighting jobs by age (by
Sharon A-B, the WO
Risk Management/Human Performance
Training Specialist, posted on 7/22.) Ab. |
| 7/24 |
Link below is to July 23, 2008 Texas Sit Report.
Its full of good info.
Calendar year 2008 to date:
1,380,599 acres burned.
181 homes lost
37 RFD firefighters burned or injured vs. 7 in 2006.
Limited moisture from Dolly but lots of wind.
ftp://ftp.txdps.state.tx.us/dem/sitrep/Texas%20Wildfires%20SITREP%20158%20%20072308.pdf
(pdf file downloads)
Midwest FMO |
| 7/24 |
Governors Executive order - Minimum wage
CAL FIRE will be exempt from this proposed cost savings measure as a public
safety agency. Really cant blame the Governor for trying to get the Legislature
off their @ss and get the budget passed. Unfortunate way to do it through the
employees. Why not cut the Legislatures pay! Hmmm
CAL FIRE Jake |
| 7/24 |
re: grass isn't always greener on the CalFire side...
Anyone remember back in 1992 when the legislature failed to pass a budget
and state employees, including CDF, didn't get paid at all? I was on
helitack that year and the pilots threatened to get up and leave unless
somebody got them some water and gatorade, so the CDF employees, who
couldn't buy anything because their government cards didn't work and
weren't even getting paid at the time, reached into their wallets and got
them something to drink. I watched CDF'ers pull into gas stations and fill
up their engines using their own cards since the fleet cards didn't work.
But just like us feds who didn't get paid for a few weeks in December 1995,
the state employees will get paid eventually. That might not prevent some
of them from losing their homes, though.
midwest afmo |
| 7/24 |
portal to portal Ab,
You said firefighters outside of R-5 getting portal to portal may
be in the minority. I think that is probably the understatement of the
year. Who besides Cal Fire gets portal to portal? Does any one
outside of R-5 get portal to portal? Maybe the posters to this forum
could let us all know, outside of Cal Fire, who is getting portal to
portal and where are they based. Portal to Portal became an issue
with some of the feds right after the 1988 season after the experience
with them in Yellowstone. 1988, we have made a lot of progress
haven't we?
the cynic |
| 7/23 |
State Teams: Currently Team 9 is transitioning to Team 5 on the BTU cplx
Team 10 is on the SHU cplx
Team 7 is on call for the Northern Region
Team 8 is on normal call for the South
Teams and ICs
Northern Region
Team 1 ?
Team 2 Bob Wallen
Team 3 George Morris
Team 4 Joe Waterman
Team 5 Tim Streblow
Southern Region
Team 6 Bill Hodson
Team 7 Dale Hutchinson
Team 8 Phill Veneris
Team 9 Rick Hutchison
Team 10 Pat Kerschen
Tim Chavez |
| 7/23 |
Wow lots of great discussion on old engines.
Several questions about models. R-5 FS model numbers were originally 10, 20,
30, 40, 50 and 60 with intermingled models based on improvements to the rigs
over the years. For example the Model 50 was built on 1 1/2 ton flat beds and
was an outgrowth of the old green hornets, hence the new designation for the 51
when it made its appearance in the late 60s early 70s.
The Model 56/58 versions made their first appearance in about 1956 and were
part of the first Green and Gray rigs. The FS converted from the deep forest
green to the light green and gray paint scheme in 1956 finally going all light
green in 1976. The Union County rig pictured is a beauty and is a 56/58 model.
The difference was that the 56 did not have the auxiliary and midship pumps as
the 58 did.
Last I heard about old 6006 was that after it was taken out of service, it
was slated to be cannibalized for the body to go into the recycle of bodies for
the M-61. I am not sure this ever happened as that recycle program died about
the same time.
Someone ask about CDF numbering system though I am not 100% positive on it
but they have for the most part have done a sequencing of numbers for their
models beginning with the model one. They actually had a model 4 which was
similar yet smaller version of the model 1 however it was a shorter wheel base
smaller tanked and 4X4. Fire geek I did see the book you referenced and its a
interesting read that is for sure.
"old green and gray guy" |
| 7/23 |
The grass isn't always greener on the CALFIRE side of the fence.... ST
www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-budget24-2008jul24,0,7487129.story
Schwarzenegger plans to slash state workers' pay till budget passes
About 200,000 employees would get the federal minimum wage, saving California
roughly $1 billion a month. They would receive their back pay after a spending
plan is enacted.
By Evan Halper, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer
5:04 PM PDT, July 23, 2008
Sacramento -- Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is planning to cut the pay of about
200,000 state workers to the federal minimum wage of $6.55 an hour until a
budget is signed, according to a draft of the governor's order obtained by The
Times.
Administration officials said Schwarzenegger is expected to sign the order early
next week as part of an effort to avert a cash crisis. The controversial move,
likely to be challenged in court by public-employee unions, would save the state
about $1 billion a month, the officials said.
Workers would be repaid their lost earnings once a budget was in place.
The order also calls for the state to immediately lay off 19,000 part-time
workers, stop overtime payments for almost all employees and cease all hiring
until a budget is enacted. The deadline for passing a budget was July 1, and
without one California may be unable to borrow billions of dollars needed to
keep the state solvent.
"Because the Legislature has failed to pass a budget and our state does not have
a rainy-day fund, this is one of a number of options we are considering to make
sure we have sufficient cash to cover our costs," said administration spokesman
Matt David.
Text of the order is at the link...
fair use disclaimer |
| 7/23 |
Thefts from working firefighters Ab,
There are bad things happening to some firefighters who were working in
Northern California on the big fires.
I thought a little exposure might be warranted to warn others what can happen
not only there, but anywhere we go. I have been guilty of too much trust in
areas like this, but fortunately without these results.
It might even be worth a thread to see if it is wide spread, or hopefully remote
incident.
One of many
one email of a young firefighter whose truck was broken into and nomex,
sweatshirt, leatherman etc stolen
one email about a firefighter that had nomex stolen from the washer at a
laundromat |
| 7/23 |
AC >From a Federal firefighter to another.. my suggestion to those who are GS
5-6 and are thinking about starting a family... it is Simple. Don't start until
you can afford it, the Govt is not obligated to support your family, you are,
they are only responsible for paying you a wage...
"Frankly a GS-08 isn't even a wage that is a starting level for most federal law
enforcement outfits and somehow I wonder why my job is considered "less
valuable" by HR. I realize much to my chagrin that a GS-08 is probably above
average in this man's army and I wonder how many 5's and 6's have families to
support."
AC |
| 7/23 |
Hotshot75:
Your post brings back some old memories. I was on the Ord fire in Punkin
Center on the Tonto NF in 1976. It was 115 degrees the day we got there,
had a couple shifts of pretty good hotline. I remember most of the main
road up through the Tonto basin was dirt then, it has long since been
paved. I was on the El Cariso Hotshots back then. The same year, we were on
the "Unknown Fire" on the Angeles. Last of November and the first few days
of December. It was the coldest fire I've ever been on in 34 fire seasons.
Someone said it was 9 below zero at 8,000 feet and the Santa Ana's were
blowing 60 plus. We had a few mile hike in from Little Jimmy campground.
The wind was blowing headlamps off of our hardhats and a chin strap was a
must if you wanted to keep your hard hat on your head. I had an icicle
hanging off of my hair from sweat by the time we got to the fire. Canteens
were freezing. It was steeper than h*ll too, like all Angeles fires.
Reality Check, who posts here often, was on the crew too. He still says it
was the coldest he's ever been in his life. And remember the engine sirens
used to wake us up at 0430 hours back then, and some guy'd be on the PA
telling everybody to wake up. Probably get a complaint filed on em
nowadays.
We also had a fire up Lytle Creek too that year. And I also remember some
the "dreams" we used to have with engine antics. Lots of good years back
then.
Thanks,
Magruder Fingers |
| 7/23 |
Fire Geek,
Maybe it should be a "Name Dick's New Engine" contest. Heh, I'm sure he and
the family
would love that. Better his than mine! I'd probably pump it dry and wreck it by
accident!
Now I AM attached to my John Deere, even have a wheelie knob and a little
pink cap
with PPE. Feel free to name that! Heh.
Mellie |
| 7/23 |
FIREGEEK, Just as firefighters become emotionally attached to their rigs, a
lot of pilots are attached to their aircraft in the same manner. We give them
names befitting of their unique personalities and handling. Most are decent,
however I remember a few birds back in the 70's with names not fit to print
here...and for good reason. Why is it they never scrap the bad ones?
Keep pluggin everyone, we're all in this together!
STAY SAFE!
TS |
| 7/23 |
Rotn,
I believe the GS 5/6 developmental program Green legs and ham is referring to is
a new one. You start as a 5 and get a 6 once you complete the program. It
consists of an additional 4 week academy "GS-6 Academy" on top of both
apprenticeship academies, as well as an additional 980 work process hours NOT
associated with the apprenticeship hours (so apprenticeship hours don't count
towards the GS-6 work process hours). It breaks down to 480 hours of fire
suppression (split between at least two areas of fire) 400 hours of fuels
management (240 must be on fire use of prescribed fire projects), 40 hours of
Dispatch, 40 hours of Prevention and 20 hours of Review Local Plans. Again,
hours gained through the apprenticeship program are not transferrable to this
program. All this is to be completed within a year, not to exceed 18 months.
I guess the idea is to get firefighters (sorry, forestry technicians) experience
working in these areas at a higher level (Senior Firefighter) instead of just
your run of the mill GS-4. The idea behind it is a good one I think, but the
problem is for those who have already finished the Apprenticeship program and
now have to vacate the driving position on the engine, leaving an engine
unstaffed, so that they can go complete these hours. I think it was just thrown
together and not fully thought through. Again, the idea behind it is great, more
training and more experience. But they need to make allowances for those who are
beyond that.
new GS 5/6 |
| 7/23 |
Ab,
Consider a “Name Mellie’s New Engine” contest! A 1949 rig in that good condition
deserves a fitting name. Maybe an acronym like the North Lake Tahoe Fire
District’s wildland engine, “BUBBA” (Big Ugly Brush Bashing Apparatus).
Fire Geek |
| 7/23 |
OK, Fire Geek, Foam Geek, Pyro, Hotshot75, Berdo, no slack, "old green and grey
guy" et al, I have to share a photo of our newest non-fed "grand damme" (said
with the correct hoity toity inflection).
Foam Geek, are you THE ORIGINAL Foam Geek?
Was it you I heard devised a way to fill three 100'lengths of coupled 4"
diameter structural fire hose with compressed air foam inflating it much
like a balloon. Then capping off one end when it was filled and reducing
the other end of it down to 1.5 " or 1" with a handled ball shutoff
valve? You found it actually contained enough stored energy to protect a
structure for at least 20 minutes with just the compressed air foam
squeezed into the hose. Hmmm, lessons for today? Is it not true that if
you placed one of these hoselays at each house in a subdivision and just
left one CAFS-equipped water tender to just drive around to periodically
keep the lines charged, it wouldn't require a Type I engine to be parked
in every driveway. All you'd really need is a task force of one handcrew
and a water tender to protect subdivisions? Ah, the fantastic but
do-able ideas forward thinkers come up with that could make a real
difference... And what was the year???
Mellie
1949 International: While not fed service, here's "our" engine at our
place on the Iron Cplx. Mellie says, "I'm not yet attached to her (the engine)
although she's classic and functional... She's very new to our family. However,
check out our
New River Gorge FOBS; people are clearly a different story." Photos
compliments of RPE. (0708)
I put it on the
Engines 20 photo page and the Fire Behavior Observer on the
Handcrews 23
photo page. Ab. |
| 7/23 |
Nor Cal Lightning Complex and other fire costs and locations as of July 23,
2008.
and summary of personnel/resources.
Response to Just Wondering's post below
Thanks, contributor.... Comments? Ab. |
| 7/23 |
IRGirl-
First off... Hi! Thanks for the additional info on the ftp site- didn't realize
the system was slowing at peaks. I would like to provide one statement of
encouragement which is, I personally think that the news media grabbing official
perimeters should be considered "part of the incident". On the last couple of
fires (way back 2+ years ago) I worked, we started posting perimeters for media
to use in their graphics alongside stories. I saved a few of those which I keep
with the official incident maps I made.
I have seen the fear in the public during the 2007 firestorms when they don't
know where the fire is and all they have are rumors. Knowledge is power and if
we can get the media to distribute official information in a timely manner it
greatly reduces the tension and fear in the public- during the fires I was
mapping stuff for the affected folks in my office using the publically available
data and it helped a ton.
I've got 4 kids visiting this weekend who all work at Google- I'll ask the boys
(kid brother & friends) if they have any contacts and see if I can find someone
to talk to about posting perimeters....
Not in the game but still care,
GISgirl |
| 7/23 |
portal to portal I cant say that agree with one contributors assertion that
portal to portal firefighters are "in the minority". Having just demobbed from
SHU Lightning Complex that I have been blessed and or cursed to have been on for
18 days I can honestly say that the enormity of Cal Fire was staggering. This
agency seems to get incrementally bigger by the season and now plans are in the
works for them to possible envelope Governor Ahnold's OES or Office of Emergency
Services which is almost as a staggering an All Risk labor force as Cal Fire.
Federal and contract workers spent nights sleeping in the fairgrounds in
Anderson, CA while Monster Trucks Rallies, freight train whistle blowing,
generators and floodlights, passersby and street traffic kept camp occupants
from getting any real rest while the Cal Fire guys showed up each morning for
briefing well rested and restaurant fed, not to mention well paid.
Although far from getting "boned" and receiving 16 hour days from the division(s)
each shift I realized after speaking to one friendly chap from Cal Fire, that
their gig is really a beneficial one and many federal firefighters have made the
transition to a better paid, better benefit source. I can only wonder how long
the federal powers that be will continue to classify me as a "Range or Forestry
Tech" instead of a firefighter when that's all I do and continue to refuse to
pay me while I am in camp or duty station, away from my family and suffering
less than perfect rest conditions while expecting me NOT to have a couple of
beers on what they carefully call "MY OWN TIME" while reserving the right to
infringe upon it as soon as it becomes a liability to them.
Frankly a GS-08 isn't even a wage that is a starting level for most federal law
enforcement outfits and somehow I wonder why my job is considered "less
valuable" by HR. I realize much to my chagrin that a GS-08 is probably above
average in this man's army and I wonder how many 5's and 6's have families to
support.
AC
Outside of CA, firefighters that are operating under portal to portal pay
may be in a minority. Ab. |
| 7/23 |
green legs and ham,
I sympathize with the staffing problems you are having on the CNF but if the
"developmental program" you are referring to is the apprenticeship academy, I
think its important to consider the positive impact cross training on a helitack
crew and hotshot crew has on the overall firefighter, even if that firefighter
ends up choosing to staff an engine after completion of their training. Speaking
as someone who attended that academy, my working knowledge of the capabilities
and limitations of those modules was greatly enhanced by the design of the
program and the cross training it emphasized. Its important not to allow an
agency's self-created staffing issues to overshadow the need for the proper
training of future fire managers.
rotn |
| 7/23 |
Fedwatcher II,
Having spent some time in " Fire Hire Jail" I will do my best to address
some of your questions/concerns.
1. What forest(s) gets the joy of trying to qualify and train the
"level 4"
candidates who FireHire attendees were mandated to hire/promote?We were
directed to hire down to the Level 3 candidates, if there were no
Level 1 or Level 2 candidates available. Most forests probably made offers to
some Level 3 candidates, but I don't know how many were actually hired. On my
forest we did make recommendations to hire a few Level 3's who were later
disqualified during the HR process. We were not required to look at any Level
4's.
2. Who will train/qualify these employees while we're in the initial
stages of a stunning season start? Some FMOs are reporting that many will
not be on board until the end of the season.
Good question, and one that was asked frequently during the hiring process.
This was particularly noticeable at the GS6 and GS5/6 Developmental positions.
The Developmental Plan puts a huge burden on the forests to get these
people trained, and it may affect some apprentices when they are pushed
back in their training to accommodate the developmental AFEOs.
3. For those promoted to the GS-6 through GS-9 positions, their
promotions
obviously created a vacancy at a lower grade. So how do promotions lessen
the actual number of vacancies? Maybe that's why I didn't do so well in Math.
As vacancies occurred backfill lists were created and jobs were filled down
to
the 5/6 developmentals. So really the vacancies still exist but they are now
at the Apprentice Level, which aren't being counted. There were some hires from
the outside, but most of the hiring was internal. I think you do math just fine,
it
was all "sleight of hand".
4. Big question: What is the region going to do to KEEP these
employees?
There's the Million Dollar Question! As far as we could tell, not much. The
only
incentive I could see was the Apprentice upgrade from GS4 to GS5, and it was
poorly advertised or understood. It is a good thing for the apprentice who has
time
in grade as a GS4 because it really becomes a payraise for them.
5. 190 vacancies as of July 17 does not equate to Mr. Rey's assurance that
all funded positions would be staffed.
Hear, hear! We are no better off then we were April 1st. If anything we are
further behind. I think the Forest Service is going to suffer some serious
growing
pains while these newly promoted personnel learn their positions. There is a
lack
of depth in experience that wasn't there during MEL hiring.
Sign me, " An escapee from Fire Hire" |
| 7/23 |
One last engine trivia question
Ab,
Do you see what I mean about firefighters becoming emotionally attached to their
engines? All of these recent posts reek of the special bond formed between man
and machine. Foam Geek describes how his rig was bigger, badder and more
powerful than all the others. Pyro assigns gender traits and referred to the
prototype Model 60 as "the old girl". I'll admit to almost feeling a little
teary eyed when I saw the famous Model 60 last year at Hole-in-the-Wall being
meticulously restored to "her" former self. The last Model 51 to go out of
service in R5 was on the Modoc. The crew affectionately referred to it as
"Christine - a Fire's Worst Nightmare" and even had a custom sign mounted on the
rear which displayed that warning.
One thing I've always wanted to know (IMWTK)
is what is the process to designation a particular engine model #? I was the
Park Service representative on the R5 mobile equipment committee when the Model
62 design was being discussed. Did you see that ugly Ford 4 X 4 with the jacked
up Marmon Harrighton suspension and the bumper-mounted headlights in this
picture?
www.wildlandfire.com/pics/eng20/nps60-61-62.jpg. After I left the committee
the 4WD Model 62 was built on an International chassis and became much more
practical with a lower center of gravity. You no longer had to be a 5.7 lead
climber to get into the thing. It made sense to designate it the Model 62
because the former production engine was the Model 61; before that was the Model
60. I've seen pictures of Model 50's, 51's and 52's. Was there ever a Model 53
or did they jump straight to the Model 60 series? There are plenty of Model 14's
out there now. Does that imply the predecessor was the Model 13?
Maybe someone from the Davis Equipment shop can answer this question. Is it
true that the CDF Model 5 was named because it was a 4WD version of the Model 1
and 4 + 1 = Model 5?
Fire Geek |
| 7/23 |
Interesting National Facts:
-- As of 07/23, 53,288 fires have burned 3,393,404 acres.
-- The 10-year average is 50,016 fires for 3,343,466 acres.
So why?. If wildland fire suppression is funded based upon the 10-year moving
average. Wouldn't it be safe to assume that we are well within the appropriate
funding that Mark Rey defended in the FY 2008 budget request for fire
preparedness and fire suppression?To paraphrase Mr. Rey, 'we are able to
reduce costs through increased management efficiencies, and by moving resources
to areas of need'.
/s/ Just Wondering |
| 7/23 |
Re Los Padres housing and if it's coming to your forest: JP Crumrine of the
Idyllwild Town Crier is looking for someone that can fill
him in on the Los Padres housing issue. He's a reliable and eloquent reporter.
If one of you from the LP would like to volunteer, I'm sure he'd keep you
anonymous if you wish. Ab. |
| 7/23 |
To those who keep saying "everyone else" except "us" is getting paid to sleep,
and eat, I would like to clarify AGAIN, that the majority of fire fighters
(State, Contract, AD, etc) DO NOT get paid to eat or sleep. I am fortunate, my
state does compensate for meal periods (with some clarifications as to when the
meal period will/will not be compensated), but we certainly are not compensated
to sleep. So, dear federal fellow fire fighters PLEASE do not think you are in
the minority. Those who are paid Portal-to-Portal are in the minority.
Best wishes on your quest for portal-to-portal |
| 7/22 |
I was fortunate enough to work on two Model 60 Engines on the Berd | |